Managed IT and Managed Security · Leesburg, VA

Compliance

What Out of Date Cybersecurity Paperwork Can Cost Your Business

If your cybersecurity paperwork says one thing and your systems do another, that gap can cost real money. Two federal suppliers just found out how much.

Capital Cyber. Sources are listed at the end of the article.

What happened in these two cases?

In November 2026, the Justice Department announced two settlements. Both turned on security records that did not match what was really in place.

On November 3, ILC Dover and ILC Astrospace agreed to pay $13 million. The Delaware firms held contracts with the Army, the Missile Defense Agency and NASA.

On November 13, Johnson Controls and two of its units agreed to pay $5 million. Their contracts were with NASA and the Departments of Defense, Energy and Justice.

Neither company admitted liability. The Justice Department says the claims are allegations only, with no finding of liability.

What was wrong with their cybersecurity paperwork?

These are the claims the Justice Department made. The details differ, but the pattern is the same.

At ILC, security plans were not written, kept or updated. Fix-it plans were not made or followed. Required security controls were not fully in place.

One ILC company never sent DoD a current self-assessment score. The other sent an old one. That is the NIST SP 800-171 score DoD contractors post in SPRS.

The ILC case also named a cloud provider. It stored protected data below the security level the contract required.

At Johnson Controls, the security plan did not meet its contracts. The fix-it plan was not properly written or followed. The company also lacked enough control over its own systems to limit who reached protected data.

What are an SSP and a POA&M?

A System Security Plan, or SSP, describes how your systems protect sensitive data today.

A Plan of Action and Milestones, or POA&M, lists what is not fixed yet, who owns each fix and when it will be done.

Both are meant to be living documents. They go stale when you add a laptop, switch a cloud tool or let a fix date slide.

Why does old paperwork turn into a legal problem?

When you sign a federal contract, you promise to meet its security terms. Your score and your plans are part of that promise.

In 2021 the Justice Department chose to use the False Claims Act against cyber fraud by contractors. That law lets the government seek money when a company claims terms it did not meet.

So a security plan that no one has opened in two years is not just untidy. It can be read as a false statement.

The fix is not more paperwork. It is paperwork that someone checks against the real systems on a set schedule.

Who reported these companies?

Insiders did. Both cases began as whistleblower suits, which the False Claims Act allows.

The ILC suit came from Philip Root, the company's former Director of Cybersecurity. He will receive $2.35 million. In the Johnson Controls case, former employee Kelly Vance will receive $850,000.

That matters for any owner. Your staff and IT team know your gaps best. The law rewards them for speaking up.

Does this apply to my business if I am not a big contractor?

If you hold or bid on federal work with protected data, yes. The rules apply to small suppliers too.

Even outside federal work, the lesson holds. Insurers, customers and auditors all ask what your records say.

Records that match reality protect you. Records that do not can hurt you.

What should I ask my IT team this week?

Start with three plain questions:

If the answers are slow or unclear, that is your sign. Talk to Capital Cyber about getting your records back in line with your systems.

  1. When was our security plan last updated, and does it match the systems we run today?
  2. What is on our fix-it list, who owns each item, and which dates have already slipped?
  3. What score did we last report to DoD, when, and would it still be true if checked tomorrow?

Frequently Asked Questions

5 QUESTIONS
What does a cybersecurity False Claims Act settlement mean for my business?

It means stale security records can become a legal risk if you hold federal contracts. Two suppliers paid $13 million and $5 million to settle claims their plans did not match reality. Neither admitted liability.

What is a System Security Plan?

A System Security Plan, or SSP, is a document that describes how your systems protect sensitive data today. Federal contracts that require NIST SP 800-171 expect it to be kept current.

What is a POA&M?

A POA&M, or Plan of Action and Milestones, is the list of security gaps not yet fixed. It names who owns each fix and when it is due. In both cases, the government said this plan was not properly kept.

Can an employee report my company for weak cybersecurity?

Yes. The False Claims Act lets private people file suits for fraud against the government and share in any recovery. Both of these cases began that way, one from the company's own cybersecurity director.

How often should a security plan be updated?

Update it whenever your systems change, such as a new laptop, cloud tool or vendor. Review it on a set schedule too. The ILC case named plans that were not periodically updated.

Talk it through in 30 minutes.

A call is a conversation, not a pitch. Tell us how your business runs and we will tell you what we would manage.

Looking for CMMC? Our Compliance Division, Capital Cyber Compliance, delivers it.

Under 25 people? Apply for an in-kind cybersecurity grant from Cyber Grants Alliance, a nonprofit. No cost to you.

Book a 30-Minute Call